MeFi mod log archive
An archive of MetaFilter's Recent Mod Actions log

Mod actions on Mefi

1,121 mod actions · Page 2 of 12

Mod note on 'You're back in the whole nepotistic patrimonial world*'

A few comments deleted. The discussion has veered into familiar election relitigation arguments and is becoming increasingly personal. Please step back from assigning blame, calling other participants complicit, or characterizing groups of voters with broad insults. Also, Pseudonymous Cognomen, please take a step back in this thread and let other members participate. If you want to continue, engage the specific issues, electoral strategy, trans rights, coalition politics, or the threadโ€™s larger subject, with care for the people affected and without treating fellow commenters as proxies for an opposing camp.

Mod note on 'You're back in the whole nepotistic patrimonial world*'

Added USPolitics tag.

Mod note on 'Ed Sheeran chooses cowardice'

(Deleted one more that i'd missed as part of the thread cleanup)

Mod note on 'Ed Sheeran chooses cowardice'

Several comments deleted. Sorry for leaving a big hole in the thread, but folks, what part of "this needs to not turn into a general thread about Palestine/Israel/Zionism" was unclear? Also, being an asshole to other users isn't acceptable even if you think they deserve it, and meta-discussion about how polite our discourse should be needs to get taken to MetaTalk.

Mod note on 'We must pace the frontier'

One deleted. jeffburdges, i believe you want the Elon Musk documentary thread?

Mod note on 'Ed Sheeran chooses cowardice'

Folks, i'm not removing anything at this point, and i'm aware that i participated in the early stages of this derail, but at this point it is getting pretty derail-y. It'd be good if comments in this thread stayed relatively focused on Sheeran, his tour, the other acts, etc. You don't have to stop talking about Palestine entirelyโ€”it's obviously a critical piece of why this is happeningโ€”but this needs to not turn into a general thread about Palestine/Israel/Zionism. (If someone would like to make a general "news about Palestine" thread, there certainly is plenty of it recently, and i invite you to do so.)

Mod note on 'The Pollinator Industrial Complex'

Fixed link in OP. Also deleted some comments related to the correction.

Mod note on 'Final Chapter of the 7 Up Documentary Series Set to Close with 70 Up'

Added "7up" and "UpSeries" tags to post.

Mod note on 'Save the Date: No Kings Is Back October 17!'

One deleted; jeffburdges, pretty sure your wage-theft comment was intended for a different thread!

Mod note on 'The Mother Tongue of All Secrets'

Nothing deleted, but folks, we all really have to get out of the habit of complaining about the headline, the format, the link source, etc. in the first couple comments in a thread. It is corrosive to discussion! If your first impulse, seeing a FPP, is irritation or disgust, it's okay to skip it and come back later (or not at all)!

Mod note on 'The island, the cafe, the dog, and the legal case'

One deleted; this thread is definitely not going to be improved by an unrelated mention of Israel.

Mod note on 'Just Make the Button Blue, Hal'

Again, folks, please keep discussion at least vaguely focused on the OP. If you want to talk more about "AI" in general, there's an open MeTa for freeform complaining.

Mod note on 'Just Make the Button Blue, Hal'

Hey, folks, i get that this stuff is just โ€ฆ all-encompassing, but please try to keep the conversation focused on this particular link rather than having it turn into another generic "AI" discussion?

Mod note on 'Japanese Grandpa Going Viral for His Cats.....'

One comment deleted. The content is clearly marked as being Instagram; if you avoid Facebook and their works (which is 100% valid!) it's totally okay to just skip this one.

Deleted mefi post 'Papyrus is a virus'

MetaFilter post Papyrus is a virus deleted. This is a duplicated post..

Mod note on '"It was winter when Elisse Burke ran her campaign of Band of Blades"'

Hey folks, no comments removed but can we stop asking "What does this link to, and why would I want to click on it?" right off the bat in a thread. It sound like a reasonable question but it tends to derail the conversation right away, As mentioned in a previous thread, if the issue is that the post doesn't summarize what the link contain well enough, that's fair feedback, but posting almost the same "What does this link to, and why would I want to click on it?" comment in every thread reads as combative rather than curious. Thanks.

Mod note on 'Save the Date: No Kings Is Back October 17!'

Fixed typo in Pritzker's name in this comment.

Mod note on 'Games for Educational Use'

One comment deleted; it was a correction comment from the OP and got missed when the title was changed.

Mod note on 'Save the Date: No Kings Is Back October 17!'

One deleted; it was not a bad comment in isolation but was unrelated to the subject of the post, and was likely to cause a derail.

Deleted mefi post 'Taken together, the portfolio tells a different story'

MetaFilter post Taken together, the portfolio tells a different story deleted. Conspiracy theories and antisemitism are not the Best of the Web.

Mod note on 'What was once an isolating experience is now a mass coming of age'

Folks, i'm not going to delete the "smith" derail because i don't think it's significant enough to warrant leaving a big hole in the thread, but this conversation really needs to get back on the rails.

Mod note on 'Games for Educational Use'

Post title corrected, as pointed out by OP.

Mod note on 'What was once an isolating experience is now a mass coming of age'

Hey folks, no comments removed but two comments in we're already off the rails. If the issue is that the post doesn't summarize the article well enough, that's fair feedback, but "what does this link to" read as combative rather than curious, and it pulled three more comments into a meta-conversation about hovering over text instead of the actual subject. Let's use the rest of the thread to actually engage with the link. Flagging and moving on rather than litigating the link format would be appreciated. Thanks.

Mod note on 'Manitoba Has an Ambitious Plan to End Homelessness'

Removed the first comment and a few replies to it. Posting a single link with the headline as a comment at the beginning of a thread lacks context so please try to articulate your point so that members understand the relevance of the comment in the context of the thread. Also, in general be careful when posting the first comments within a thread, as it can easily derail the conversation right of the bat.

Mod note on 'You've been hit by a smooth criminal'

Nothing deleted, but note that "open season" can be interpreted as a call for real violence and it makes people uncomfortable and picks up flags. Exercise caution in the future, please!

Mod note on '"Of course I'm not deceiving you."'

Fixed Guy Williams' name in this comment; removed a comment about the correction.

Mod note on 'Predictive Intelligence Targeting'

Added USPolitics tag. Please carry on.

Mod note on 'What the PrSM is meant to do'

Added USPolitics tag. Please carry on.

Mod note on 'Free Thread - Because it's good for you'

Nothing removed, but please note that "pansy" is often considered to be homophobic, and is not generally acceptable language for MetaFilter.

Mod note on 'I'm Not Remarkable'

Two deleted. Apple's history with the IDF is potentially relevant to this conversation, but it is not okay to accuse other members of being paid shills. (One was deleted for that reason, and the other was a reply to the deleted comment.)

Mod note on 'Itโ€™s bizarre to use something daily and not engage with it critically'

Two comments deleted as noise.

Mod note on 'Orient your shells left-right? or top-bottom? Life says: why not both?'

Fixed wording in OP at user's request.

Mod note on 'LEAD PIPE DX'

Removed extra querystring params from youtube link in OP.

Mod note on 'there was very little sense that working, in itself, could be dignified'

Fixed a typo in the OP!

Mod note on 'constrained but not powerless'

One comment deleted for being in the wrong thread. jenfullmoon, i believe you want the MrBeast thread!

Mod note on 'A Lion in Winter Shorts'

Fixed link in this comment.

Mod note on 'Cheese Bank'

Fixed a typo in OP.

Deleted mefi post 'BMW drivers are obnoxious, and cockroach milk is nutritious.'

Mod note on 'Decade of work helps remote island's native wildlife "return to 1616."'

Two accidental comments removed.

Mod note on 'MrBeast x James Patterson'

Corrected book title as requested. Please carry on.

Mod note on 'Watermarking of AI Text.'

dsword: Whoops! Apparently i'm the one who was confused, then; i've restored your comment and edited the previous mod note!

Mod note on 'RIP, Paris Climate Accord'

One deleted. pantamisiac, sorry to see you go; if you want to talk about it, feel free to reach out via the Contact Form.

Mod note on 'Watermarking of AI Text.'

One deleted for being in the wrong thread. dsword, i believe you want the MetaPi thread!
Restored the comment; it was in the right thread after all!

Mod note on 'GrassGPT'

One deleted for being hostile.

Mod note on 'The task is to understand what our fears reveal'

One deleted (wrong thread!)

Mod note on 'The AI Bailout Could Be Baked Into the AI Bubble'

One deleted at user's request.

Mod note on '๐Ÿค˜๐Ÿค˜๐Ÿค˜ Female Fronted Metal & Punk #24 ๐Ÿค˜๐Ÿค˜๐Ÿค˜'

Fixed typo in post.

Mod note on 'Today in Competitive Authoritarianism'

One comment removed as requested.

Mod note on 'โ€œI Didnโ€™t Chase The Dollar. I Never Did.โ€'

Updated post with the Direct Guardian link.

Mod note on 'Color Counter'

Two comments removed. Folks, your enthusiasm is appreciated, but please don't ruin the game for other people who might want to play it by posting giant lists of colors!

Mod note on 'Retirement is Dead'

UPDATE: I apologize to House Hippolyta for how i handled the "possible LLM" flags yesterday; i absolutely should have done more due diligence before making a public mod note. There is more discussion over in the ongoing MeTa about LLM comments.

Mod note on 'Canada/US Trade Talks Collapse'

Several comments deleted. Full transparency: three of the four were mine, and the fourth was a reply to me. They were fighty and were going to cause a derail, so i would've requested deletion, but i'm also the only mod available for the next several hours, so i had to do the deletion myself. Sorry, folks, i wasn't modeling good behavior there.

Mod note on 'Retirement is Dead'

House Hippolyta, folks have flagged your comments: it looks as though you may have used an LLM to generate at least portions of them. Please note that this is against the content policy and you need to write your comments yourself. This was a bad call; i've posted an apology below.

Mod note on 'Bureau of Minor Sufferings'

Added "AI" tag. I don't think we have consensus on whether "AI"-generated content needs its own tag, separate from "AI" (which is more for posts which are about "AI"), but this will work at least for now.

Mod note on 'Lego without corners'

Highlights link fixed in OP, and one comment about the correction deleted.

Mod note on 'Bureau of Minor Sufferings'

No comments removed, but let's please not have discussions of whether something is AI or not within the post itself.

Mod note on 'Bureau of Minor Sufferings'

Fixed typo in the title.

Mod note on 'Strange game. The only way to win is not to play'

Fixed broken link in OP and deleted two comments about the correction.

Mod note on 'Balcony solar comes to UK'

Made link in this comment clickable.

Mod note on 'Some more games for you to play'

Fixed typo in OP at user's request.

Mod note on 'โ€œOh.โ€'

Fixed broken link in this comment. Rash, if this isn't the link you intended, let me know and i can change it; we tried to get in touch but never heard back.

Mod note on 'Aboriginal artist recreating oldest living weaving practice with glass'

Removed a wrong-thread comment at the user's request.

Mod note on 'Open Executive'

Made link clickable in this comment.

Mod note on 'AI Analyzes AI Behavior'

Fixed broken link in OP. Folks: yes, the primary link is LLM-generated text. It's clearly marked as such both in the post's text and using the "AI" tag. I swear we are working out policies about how to treat slop links in post, but that's a longer-term process; in the meantime, it really is okay to just skip things.

Mod note on 'How to Spot a Psychopath'

Fixed typos in this comment and this comment.

Mod note on 'Scientists say Australia is the best place to go in a catastrophe'

Fixed the borked markup in this comment.

Deleted mefi post '"Beauty emerges from chaos, art born from the ruins of play"'

MetaFilter post "Beauty emerges from chaos, art born from the ruins of play" deleted. Seems to be AI-post with not much substance. Maybe not best for the site.

Mod note on 'The Age of Spiraling Machines'

One comment removed for violating the content policy. Even in threads about "AI", if you use an LLM to generate your comment you must label it as such. (Sorry, folks, i didn't spot this one earlier and it wasn't flagged until just now.)

Mod note on 'The Quiet Grief of Adult Friendship'

Please be aware that this post is being flagged as probable LLM output. I'm not removing it, but i wanted to leave this note here so folks know if they want to avoid it. We really are still working on guidelines about how to deal with this sort of thing, but in the meantime, please do not derail the conversation; either read it or don't.

Mod note on 'Why Is Anti-Indigenous Racism on the Rise?'

Folks, please be careful with each other and with the topic of the thread. A couple notes:
  • Indigenous/First Nations people are welcome to express their feelings, and those feelings aren't automatically destructive to the thread. If you think something violates the guidelines, flag it, but it's not anyone's job to tone-police angry victims of racism.
  • While there certainly are commonalities between anti-Indigenous racism in Canada and anti-Black racism in the US (and other varieties of racism globally), please use care so as not to derail the thread away from the topic of anti-Indigenous racism in Canada.

Mod note on 'Open Executive'

Fixed typo in post title/URL; also made links clickable in this comment.

Mod note on '"Freedom is the right of all sentient beings."'

Removed two comments (one in the wrong thread, one correcting themself about the thread). Left one reply up because it also had a bunch of other info in it.

Deleted mefi post 'Lake News'

MetaFilter post Lake News deleted. News posts are fine but they have to actually have *words* in them.

Mod note on 'Hey pledge, can you write up this FPP for me RIGHT NOW!'

Folks, please do remember to let threads breathe rather than arguing in detail with everyone who disagrees with you. Also, anoldfriend6, check your MeMail.

Mod note on '2026, the year of Linux on the set-top'

Edited this comment to remove misinformation, at user's request, and removed two replies about the misinformation.

Mod note on 'Meds that make the heat worse'

Added archive link to OP at user's request, and deleted a comment about the correction.

Deleted mefi post ''Cause I've Seen Blue Skies Through The Tears In My Eyes...'

Mod note on 'Steganography, previously'

Corrected post from 14th century to 16th century.

Mod note on '"Little clarity is gleaned from the strange one-show wonder"'

Made link clickable in this comment.

Mod note on 'Cute Animal Farm'

Fixed tags in OP to hopefully avoid causing annoyance to screenreader users.

Deleted mefi post 'Trade policy by Dunning-Kruger'

Deleted mefi post 'Trade policy by Dunning-Kruger'

Deleted mefi post 'Carney Reads the Clock Like a Pro Wrestler'

MetaFilter post Carney Reads the Clock Like a Pro Wrestler deleted. This post is a single link to Substack and members are reporting it as AI Slop. OP has now retracted his post. Please direct your comments about this subject to this general thread instead

Deleted mefi post 'Carney Reads the Clock Like a Pro Wrestler'

MetaFilter post Carney Reads the Clock Like a Pro Wrestler deleted. This post is a single link to Substack and members are reporting it as AI Slop. OP has now retracted his post please direct your comments about this subject to this general thread instead

Mod note on 'Comedian/musician Reggie Watts accused of coercion by multiple women'

The words suicide both in the content warning and in the post have been un-redacted and the content has been placed below the fold.

Mod note on 'Carney Reads the Clock Like a Pro Wrestler'

Folks, please pause on any further back and forth in this thread about the use of AI. There is a MeTa where you can share your opinions on how you would like these types of posts to be moderated etc. Thank you.

Mod note on 'Europeโ€™s heat has become too lethal to ignore'

One deleted, seems to be posted in wrong thread.

Mod note on 'Comedian/musician Reggie Watts accused of coercion by multiple women'

As highlighted by a user above, please refrain from derailing this thread to discuss the issue of redacting certain words and take it to MeTa if need be.

Mod note on 'Europeโ€™s heat has become too lethal to ignore'

Edited archive link in OP and deleted two comments about the correction.

Mod note on 'Canada/US Trade Talks Collapse'

Yeah, i'm not going to re-delete it, but let's not continue with the military derail, please.

Mod note on 'Canada/US Trade Talks Collapse'

One deleted; wrong thread.I misread something badly; i've restored the comment. Sorry, Paul Slade!

Mod note on 'Canada/US Trade Talks Collapse'

Also, folks, the "how people are treated" derail should either stop or go elsewhere.

Mod note on 'The cleverness of the arrangement is it leaves no one to rebel against'

Added Substack tag, and one comment deleted. Folks, Pangram is more accurate than other "AI" detectors, but it's less accurate on this kind of very formal writing than it is on other kinds of writing, because this kind of thing is overrepresented in the training corpus. Philosophers, in particular, are trained to write like this. So i don't know if the content at this link is "AI" or not. And while i personally hate "AI", the community keeps making it pretty clear that they're not thrilled about every discussion getting derailed by that question. If you must say something, please keep it to one comment; but in general, the better practice is probably to flag it to our attention and/or just not engage with the post.

Mod note on 'Canada/US Trade Talks Collapse'

One deleted; we do not need to relitigate the 2024 US election in a thread that's primarily about Canada.

Mod note on 'Its hands are indecent and have been censored out'

Fixed broken markup in OP and deleted a comment about the correction.

Mod note on 'Suck It Suits'

One comment deleted at user's request, and a second comment deleted because the user was under the mistaken impression that this is an obit thread (Felicia Day is not dead!) Also fixed the spelling of Patton Oswalt's name in this comment.

Mod note on 'The Catcher in the AI'

Fixed typo in OP.

Mod note on 'Oh Shit! I'm Autistic'

One comment deleted at user's request. I've added the "AI" tag to this post so folks who want to skip this kind of thing entirely have the tools to do so. Also, folks, this comment has gotten flagged a few times for being LLM-generated, and it's definitely true that part of it is, but that part is directly quoted from the linked source, which is currently a weird gray area. hankscorpio83, you're not in trouble! But it'd be good if in the future you would use the <blockquote> tag or otherwise make clearer that you are quoting content from elsewhere, especially if that content bears the hallmarks of being generated by an LLM.

Mod note on 'Solar Eclipse Cats'

Deleted a dupurrlicate comment.

Mod note on 'Trans New Weird'

Thanks, DoT! I've edited my previous mod note to reflect correct information. (Folks have definitely been using both)